Side by side
| Rayobyte | Webshare | |
|---|---|---|
| Manual swap | Replace a single static ISP IP, keep the rest | Manual replacement |
| Automatic | Rotating products replace IPs per session | Proxies failing status checks for about 15 minutes are replaced automatically |
| Scheduled | No | Recurring replacement |
| API | Documented programmatic access | Replacement endpoints in the API |
At the time of writing. See replacing Rayobyte IPs and Webshare proxy replacements.
Webshare's replacement system
Webshare offers three modes: automatic replacement of dead proxies, manual replacement on request, and recurring replacement on a schedule. Its API exposes them, so you can automate replacement based on your own success metrics.
Rayobyte's approach
Rayobyte lets you swap individual static ISP IPs while keeping the rest, which is ideal for account work where only one identity is burned. Its rotating products avoid the problem entirely by handing you a different IP each session.
When to replace
- One IP fails on a target while others work.
- Constant CAPTCHAs from one IP.
- The IP's account was banned and you're starting fresh.
Don't replace working account IPs; changing an account's IP can trigger checks. See IP reputation and proxies.
Residential tip: A common split is Webshare for cheap per-IP lists and Rayobyte for residential traffic, mobile IPs or managed scraping. Our replacing Rayobyte IPs covers each Rayobyte product.
A real-world example
A scraping team runs 1,000 Webshare datacenter IPs and logs success per IP per domain. A nightly job flags IPs that fall far below the average on any domain and calls Webshare's replacement API for them; dead proxies are already replaced automatically. Its 40 Rayobyte static ISP IPs for account work are handled differently: an IP is swapped only when the account behind it is retired or clearly flagged, because changing a working account's IP can trigger security checks.
Detecting flagged IPs
- Log IP, domain, status and block indicator for every request.
- Compute daily success per IP per domain.
- Flag IPs well below the list average.
- Retest at low volume before replacing.
Pros and cons for replacements
Rayobyte
- Swap one static ISP IP and keep the rest.
- Rotating products avoid the problem entirely.
Webshare
- Automatic replacement of dead proxies.
- Manual and recurring replacement, controllable by API.
Budget tip: To test the Webshare side of this comparison, start with Webshare's free plan: 10 datacenter proxies and 1 GB a month with no card. See our complete Webshare guide.
Bottom line
Webshare's replacement system is the more automated; Rayobyte's single swaps suit careful account work.
For the bigger picture beyond our three partners, read our best proxies buyer's guide, and see cheap proxies for ways to cut cost per successful request.
Proxy tip: If your residential usage goes up and down, compare Geonode: its per-GB residential bandwidth doesn't expire, so you only pay for what you use. See Rayobyte vs Geonode vs Webshare.
Key takeaways
- Webshare offers automatic, manual and recurring replacement, with API control.
- Rayobyte swaps single static IPs and uses rotation elsewhere.
- Track success per IP to know when to replace.
- Leave stable account IPs alone.
FAQ
Does Webshare replace dead proxies automatically?
Yes, according to its documentation, after about 15 minutes of failed status checks.
Can I replace one Rayobyte IP without changing the rest?
Yes, on static ISP proxies.
Should I schedule replacements?
For scraping lists, sometimes; for accounts, no.
Will a replacement IP be in the same country?
Replacements generally come from the location you bought; check details in each dashboard.
How quickly are replacements issued?
Webshare's automatic replacement kicks in after about 15 minutes of failed checks; manual swaps on both are usually quick.
Do replacements cost extra?
Neither lists a fee at the time of writing; check plan limits.
Editorial note: Proxy providers change their pools, features and prices often, so treat any figures here as typical ranges at the time of writing and confirm current terms with the provider before you buy.