Best value per dollar on each
| Product | Best value at | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Datacenter IPs | Webshare | 100 IPs for about $2.99 a month at list price |
| Static ISP IPs | Webshare | From $0.30 per IP base |
| Residential GB | Geonode | Under $1/GB at list prices, doesn't expire |
| Managed scraping | Geonode | 1,500 free Scraper API requests a month |
| Free proxies | Webshare | 10 proxies, 1 GB a month, no card |
So the budget playbook is usually: per-IP products from Webshare, per-GB residential from Geonode. See cheap proxies for the wider market.
Sample monthly setups (list prices)
$10 a month: a hobby scraper
- Webshare free plan for development.
- Webshare 250 shared datacenter IPs (about $7.50).
- Geonode Scraper API free tier for a few hard pages.
$25 a month: a small monitoring project
- Webshare 500 shared datacenter IPs (about $14).
- A 10 GB Geonode residential purchase (about $9) for protected sites, used over several months if needed.
$50 a month: a freelancer with clients
- Webshare 20 static residential IPs (about $6 base) for client accounts.
- Webshare 1,000 shared datacenter IPs (about $27).
- A 20 GB Geonode residential balance (about $17), topped up as needed.
Traps that waste a small budget
- Monthly residential plans you don't use up. If your residential use is irregular, non-expiring GB stretches further.
- More datacenter IPs to fix blocks. If a site blocks datacenter, more IPs won't help.
- Paying for dedicated where shared works, for lenient scraping.
- Shared IPs for accounts, which can cost you the accounts.
- Yearly billing too early. Only commit once usage is stable.
Stretching the budget further
- Fetch HTML or JSON instead of rendering pages.
- Block images and media in browsers.
- Cache and skip unchanged pages.
- Track cost per 1,000 results and cut the worst performers.
Proxy tip: To test the Geonode side of this comparison, a small residential balance from Geonode is enough, and it doesn't expire if you pause. See our complete Geonode guide for its full product range.
Verdict
On a small budget, combine them: Webshare for free and per-IP products, Geonode for residential bandwidth and free managed scraping.
Monthly spend tracker
| Line | Provider | Budget | Actual | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Datacenter list | Webshare | $8 | ||
| Account IPs | Webshare | $6 | ||
| Residential balance top-up | Geonode | $10 | Leftovers carry over | |
| Scraper API | Geonode | $0 | Free tier |
Reviewing a table like this monthly keeps a small budget under control.
Getting more from each dollar
- Move any target that works on datacenter off residential.
- Cut page weight before buying more GB.
- Cancel IPs you haven't used in a month.
- Use free tiers for testing and low-volume tasks.
When to spend more
Increase the budget when a clear outcome justifies it: a client paying for a report, a product feature that needs data, or a monitoring program that saves more than it costs. Tie spend to value.
Budget tip: The cheapest way to settle this comparison is to test both: Webshare has a free datacenter plan, and Geonode offers a low-cost residential trial. Run the same targets through each. See Webshare pricing explained.
A real-world example
A solo developer runs three side projects on $20 a month. Webshare's free plan covers development, a 250-IP shared list (about $7.50) handles two scrapers, and a Geonode residential balance of 10 GB (about $9) lasts several months for the one project that needs residential IPs. Geonode's free Scraper API tier covers a handful of JavaScript-heavy pages each month at no cost.
For the bigger picture beyond these two providers, read our best proxies buyer's guide, and see cheap proxies for ways to cut cost per successful request.
Key takeaways
- Buy per-IP products from Webshare and per-GB residential from Geonode.
- Use Webshare's free plan and Geonode's free Scraper API tier wherever they suffice.
- Non-expiring residential balances stretch small budgets.
- Don't buy more datacenter IPs to fix blocks.
- Track spend monthly and tie it to outcomes.
FAQ
What's the cheapest useful proxy setup?
Webshare's free plan, then a small shared datacenter list.
Is residential affordable on a small budget?
Yes, if you buy per GB with no expiry and keep page sizes small.
Should I commit to yearly billing to save money?
Only after a couple of stable months.
What's the minimum I can spend on residential proxies?
The smallest residential purchase on either provider, or a low-cost trial; check current minimums.
Is shared datacenter good enough on a budget?
For lenient sites, yes.
How do I avoid surprise charges?
Use pay as you go where possible, set reminders for renewals and check trial terms.
Editorial note: Proxy providers change their pools, features and prices often, so treat any figures here as typical ranges at the time of writing and confirm current terms with the provider before you buy.