Reddit ads: should you run with comments on or off?
When you create a Reddit ad you can decide whether people are allowed to comment on it. It looks like a small setting. It is one of the biggest decisions in the campaign, because it determines whether your ad is a message or a conversation.
What happens with comments off
The ad behaves like advertising on any other platform. People see it, click it or scroll past. Nobody can reply underneath it.
Advantages:
- Full control over what appears next to your brand.
- No moderation workload.
- Predictable and safe for regulated or sensitive industries.
Disadvantages:
- You lose the social proof that positive comments provide.
- Some redditors see closed comments as a sign that a brand is avoiding questions.
For most companies, most of the time, comments off is the sensible way to start. You get the targeting, the audience and the price advantages of Reddit without taking on a public discussion you are not staffed to handle.
What happens with comments on
The ad becomes a thread. People ask questions, share experiences, make jokes and sometimes criticise. Everyone who sees the ad can see the discussion.
Advantages:
- Real questions answered in public act as powerful proof.
- Engagement can improve how the ad performs in the auction.
- You learn exactly what the market thinks, in its own words.
Disadvantages:
- Criticism is visible, and a slow or defensive reply makes it worse.
- It needs somebody watching and answering, quickly and well.
- A weak product claim will be found and quoted.
Who should choose which
Comments off suits: first campaigns, small teams, regulated sectors such as finance and health, and any brand with a known controversy.
Comments on suits: companies with a strong product, a thick skin and people available to reply within hours. Developer tools, cybersecurity products and other technical categories often benefit, because expert buyers want to see how a vendor handles hard questions.
If you open comments, do it properly
- Reply fast. A question answered within an hour builds trust. One ignored for two days does the opposite.
- Reply like a person. Use a name. Skip the corporate template.
- Concede fair points. "You are right, we do not support that yet" wins more respect than any spin.
- Never argue to win. You are not writing for the critic. You are writing for the hundreds of silent readers.
- Do not delete criticism unless it breaks the rules. Redditors notice, and screenshots travel.
A sensible way to start
Many advertisers begin with comments off, find the communities and messages that work, and only then decide whether opening comments in selected places would add value. That sequence keeps the risk low while the campaign is still learning.
How Team of Monkeys handles it
Our standard service runs your ads with comments off, and it is what our simple fee of 25% of ad spend covers. That gives you strategy, community selection, native ad copy, build, launch and optimisation, without exposure to an unmanaged thread.
Running with comments on is a different kind of work: it means being present in every thread your ads create. If you believe your campaign would benefit from it, raise it on the first call and we will tell you honestly whether we think it is a good idea for your product and what it would involve.
Either way, the aim is the same. The campaigns we run deliver click-through and conversion rates that lead the industry, in many industries, and we choose the comment setting that protects that result.
If we think your product would be torn apart on Reddit with comments on, or would not succeed there at all, we will tell you before you spend any money. Our goal is repeat business, and you will only come back if you are consistently happy with the results.
Common questions
Can people still criticise my brand if comments are off?
Yes, in their own posts elsewhere on Reddit. Turning comments off controls the space under your ad, not the whole platform. That is another reason honest ad claims matter.
Do ads with comments on perform better?
Sometimes. A lively, positive thread can lift engagement. A negative one can sink the ad. The result depends on the product, the community and the quality of the replies.
Want to know if Reddit will work for your product?
Team of Monkeys is a Reddit advertising agency that plans, writes, launches and manages campaigns with click-through and conversion rates that lead the industry, across many industries. If we do not think your product will succeed on Reddit, we will tell you before you spend any money. Our goal is repeat business, and we only earn that when you are consistently happy with the results. See our simple pricing or book a 30 minute call.