Why use two providers
No single provider is best at everything. Rayobyte and Geonode complement each other well, and using both also gives you resilience: if one network struggles on a key target for a week, you can shift traffic.
A sensible split
| Job | Route to | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Everyday residential, irregular volumes | Geonode | Lower small-volume price, no expiry |
| Long logged-out sessions | Geonode | 24-hour sticky sessions |
| ZIP-level or device OS targeting | Rayobyte | Only Rayobyte offers it |
| Lenient high-volume targets | Rayobyte rotating datacenter | From $0.30/GB |
| Fast scraping with ISP trust | Rayobyte rotating ISP | No Geonode equivalent |
| Budget account IPs | Geonode ISP | Cheaper per IP |
| Hardest targets via a proxy endpoint | Rayobyte Web Unblocker | Drop-in for existing code |
| Content for LLMs | Geonode Scraper API | Markdown output |
| Huge untargeted crawls | Rayobyte Scale Residential | Around a cent per GB |
A simple router
import os
from urllib.parse import urlparse
import requests
PROXIES = {
"geonode_resi": os.environ["GEONODE_RESI_PROXY"],
"rayobyte_dc": os.environ["RAYOBYTE_DC_PROXY"],
"rayobyte_resi_zip": os.environ["RAYOBYTE_RESI_ZIP_PROXY"],
}
ROUTES = {
"easy-shop.example": "rayobyte_dc",
"hard-shop.example": "geonode_resi",
"local-search.example": "rayobyte_resi_zip",
}
FALLBACK = {"rayobyte_dc": "geonode_resi", "geonode_resi": "rayobyte_resi_zip"}
def fetch(url):
route = ROUTES.get(urlparse(url).hostname, "rayobyte_dc")
for name in (route, FALLBACK.get(route)):
if not name:
break
proxy = PROXIES[name]
try:
r = requests.get(url, proxies={"http": proxy, "https": proxy}, timeout=30)
if r.ok:
return r
except requests.RequestException:
pass
return NoneEach proxy URL comes from the relevant dashboard. See Rayobyte with Python.
Failover
Route each domain to a primary provider, and fail over to the other when success drops. Track success per domain per provider daily and adjust the table. This is also a fair, ongoing comparison of the two. See proxy rotation strategies.
Residential tip: Many teams end up using more than one provider: Rayobyte for ZIP and ASN targeted residential traffic or its Scraping API, Geonode for non-expiring per-GB bandwidth and long sticky sessions. Start with our complete Rayobyte guide.
Keeping costs under control
- Put each provider's spend in a separate budget line.
- Review cost per successful result per domain monthly.
- Avoid duplicate requests: fail over only after a real failure.
- Use each provider's trial or small purchase before adding a route.
Adding Webshare
Webshare adds cheap per-IP datacenter and static residential lists and a permanent free plan. See using all three together.
A real-world example
A marketplace analytics company routes about 2 million requests a month. Lenient sources (around 70%) go to Rayobyte rotating datacenter. Protected marketplaces go to Geonode residential, bought in non-expiring blocks. ZIP-level delivery checks go to Rayobyte residential. When Geonode's success on one marketplace dips for a few days, the router fails that marketplace over to Rayobyte residential automatically, then switches back once a daily check shows recovery.
Proxy tip: To test the Geonode side of this comparison, a small residential balance from Geonode is enough, and it doesn't expire if you pause. See our complete Geonode guide for its full product range.
Pros and cons of a two-provider setup
Benefits
- Each provider handles what it's cheapest at.
- Failover protects against a bad week on one network.
- Ongoing, fair comparison data.
Costs
- Two dashboards and two bills.
- A routing table to maintain.
- A little more monitoring.
If you're still shortlisting, compare these options with the wider market in our best proxies guide, and use our cheap proxies guide to estimate a sensible budget. To understand the IP type behind this, read our residential proxies guide.
Budget tip: If you want a cheap proxy to try this with, Webshare has a free plan with 10 datacenter proxies and 1 GB of bandwidth a month, no card required. Paid lists let you pick proxy count, bandwidth and location. See Rayobyte vs Geonode vs Webshare.
Key takeaways
- Use Geonode for everyday non-expiring residential, long sessions and Markdown APIs.
- Use Rayobyte for ZIP and OS targeting, rotating datacenter and ISP, the Web Unblocker and huge untargeted crawls.
- Route by domain with failover between providers.
- Review cost per success per domain every month.
FAQ
Is it worth paying two providers?
For many teams, yes: each provider's strengths lower total cost, and failover protects against bad weeks.
How do I split traffic?
By domain and job, using a routing table and success metrics.
Does using both complicate code?
Barely. Both use standard proxy URLs; only the strings differ.
Editorial note: Proxy providers change their pools, features and prices often, so treat any figures here as typical ranges at the time of writing and confirm current terms with the provider before you buy.