Why combine them
Webshare and Rayobyte overlap less than you'd think. Webshare is the cheapest way to buy IPs by the list; Rayobyte is strong at residential volume, mobile and managed unblocking. Together they cover almost any workload at low cost, with failover between networks.
A routing table
| Job | Route to | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Lenient sites, high volume | Webshare datacenter list | About 3 cents per IP |
| Account IPs on a budget | Webshare static residential | About $0.30 per IP |
| Protected sites, 50 GB+ residential | Rayobyte Premium Residential | Cheaper tiers, pay as you go |
| ZIP or device OS checks | Rayobyte | Device OS only on Rayobyte |
| Mobile-first platforms | Rayobyte mobile | Webshare has no mobile |
| A few impossible sites | Rayobyte Web Unblocker | Drop-in proxy endpoint |
| Development and CI | Webshare free plan | Free forever |
A simple router
import os
from urllib.parse import urlparse
import requests
PROXIES = {
"ws_dc": os.environ["WEBSHARE_DC_PROXY"],
"ry_resi": os.environ["RAYOBYTE_RESI_PROXY"],
"ry_unblock": os.environ["RAYOBYTE_UNBLOCKER_PROXY"],
}
ROUTES = {"hard-shop.example": "ry_resi", "impossible.example": "ry_unblock"}
FALLBACK = {"ws_dc": "ry_resi", "ry_resi": "ry_unblock"}
def fetch(url):
name = ROUTES.get(urlparse(url).hostname, "ws_dc")
while name:
p = PROXIES[name]
try:
r = requests.get(url, proxies={"http": p, "https": p}, timeout=30)
if r.ok:
return r
except requests.RequestException:
pass
name = FALLBACK.get(name)
return NoneUse Webshare's backbone gateway URL for the datacenter list, or pick IPs from the downloaded list yourself. See Rayobyte with Python.
Cost control
- Keep separate budgets per provider.
- Fail over only on real failures.
- Review cost per success per domain monthly.
- Move domains back down a tier when they start working on cheaper proxies.
Residential tip: A common split is Webshare for cheap per-IP lists and Rayobyte for residential traffic, mobile IPs or managed scraping. Our our complete Rayobyte guide covers each Rayobyte product.
Adding Geonode
Geonode adds non-expiring residential bandwidth, 24-hour sessions and Markdown APIs. See using all three together.
A real-world example
A price comparison site runs about 3 million requests a month. Its default route is a 2,000-IP Webshare datacenter list (about $50). Protected retailers, around 150 GB a month, go to Rayobyte residential at the $2 tier ($300). Three retailers that defeat both go through Rayobyte's Web Unblocker. When a Webshare batch underperforms for a week on one retailer, the router fails that retailer over to Rayobyte automatically until the batch recovers.
Monitoring the split
- Log provider, product, domain, status and bytes per request.
- Chart success per domain per provider.
- Alert when a route drops below threshold.
- Review monthly whether domains can move to a cheaper route.
Pros and cons of combining them
Benefits
- Webshare's cheap IPs handle most traffic.
- Rayobyte covers residential volume, mobile and hard targets.
- Failover between networks.
Costs
- Two dashboards and bills.
- A routing table to maintain.
Budget tip: To test the Webshare side of this comparison, start with Webshare's free plan: 10 datacenter proxies and 1 GB a month with no card. See our complete Webshare guide.
Bottom line
For most scraping and account businesses, the combination costs less than either provider alone.
For the bigger picture beyond our three partners, read our best proxies buyer's guide, and see cheap proxies for ways to cut cost per successful request.
Proxy tip: If your residential usage goes up and down, compare Geonode: its per-GB residential bandwidth doesn't expire, so you only pay for what you use. See Rayobyte vs Geonode vs Webshare.
Key takeaways
- Use Webshare for cheap lists, accounts on a budget and free development.
- Use Rayobyte for residential at volume, mobile, fine targeting and managed unblocking.
- Route by domain with failover.
- Review cost per success monthly.
FAQ
Is combining providers complicated?
No. Both use standard proxy URLs; only the strings differ.
Which should be the default route?
Usually the cheapest option that works for most targets, often Webshare datacenter.
When should a domain move to Rayobyte?
When its block rate on cheaper proxies passes your threshold.
Does using two providers raise my bill?
Usually it lowers it, because each provider handles the traffic it's cheapest for.
How do I decide which provider is the default?
Make the default whichever is cheapest for most of your traffic, usually a Webshare list.
Do I need separate code for each?
No, only separate proxy strings in configuration.
Editorial note: Proxy providers change their pools, features and prices often, so treat any figures here as typical ranges at the time of writing and confirm current terms with the provider before you buy.